Keep Your Ad and Magic, Toys R Us

There is a petition circulating on the internet asking Toys R Us CEO Antonio Urcelay to pull a recent advertisement which chronicles an outing with a group of children from the Boys and Girls Club and Big Brothers/Big Sisters.  The children were led to believe they were going on a field trip to the woods but instead were brought to Toys R Us.  There they were allowed to pick out a toy—courtesy of the company.  The children’s joy at the toy store was infectious compared to their initial reaction to the purported field trip—which was more resigned complacency if not boredom.

And therein lies the root of the petition, which accuses Toys R Us of making a mockery of environmental education and putting an unneeded if not dangerous emphasis on consumerism.

While I appreciate the passion of those who have already signed, I will not be one of them.

As a parent, bringing magic to my children’s lives is one of my greatest joys—and the element of surprise plays a big part.  Just yesterday I listened to a colleague tell the story of his eight-year-old nephew whose grandparents surprised him with a trip to Disney.  His suitcase was packed and in the trunk.  He got in the car thinking he was going on an errand.  They arrived at the airport and asked him if he wanted to go on a trip.  He thought they meant to New Jersey to visit relatives.  They said, “How about instead we go to Disney?”

Or what about the parent who says to his son or daughter, “Let’s go to the library,” but instead takes a detour to the local movie theater  and surprises him/her with a movie date?

My colleague’s parents were not making a mockery of errand-running or visiting relatives with their ruse.  The parent who went to the movies instead of the library is not dismissing literacy.  In both scenarios, the adults were trying to create a little bit of magic for children—exactly the premise behind the Toys R Us event.

Now, for those who feel Toys R Us went too far in portraying the children as bored at the prospect of going to the woods, I get it.  I am a teacher.  I understand the discomfit we all feel when children, the greatest truth-tellers on our planet, yawn or otherwise seem disinterested in what we have planned.  But we know they do.  As parents, we correct and let them know it’s not appropriate; advertisers, I suspect, might capitalize on the juxtaposition.

Lastly, and perhaps most significantly, the author of the petition refers to the children who participate in this experience as “disadvantaged.”  As a child who grew up “disadvantaged,” I admit I may have a heightened sensitivity to the use of this adjective to describe a child’s situation which has nothing to do with him or her and for which the child bears no responsibility; however, as much as the author feels this ad does a disservice to the efforts of environmental educators, I feel slinging adjectives onto children is equally dangerous—maybe even moreso.  I remember how it felt as a young child to be termed “poor,” “disadvantaged,” or “needy.”  I am forty-five years old and can still feel it.

In truth, raising children is all about balance.  Children should be in nature.  They should also play with toys.  But no matter, they should be allowed to experience and believe in magic.  And at the very least they should be safe from adults hurling discriminating labels that wreak havoc with their self-concept—because no amount of magic can make that better.

[NOTE:  As of this afternoon, the word “disadvantaged” was removed from the petition.  While I am certainly grateful for the removal, it remains disturbing that roughly 600 people read and signed the petition with the word included.  Further, it is equally disconcerting that the content of any petition can change once people have signed it.  Please think about this before you sign your next petition.]

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Keep Your Ad and Magic, Toys R Us

  1. There is more here. The element of surprise is one thing, but there is also trust at issue. Kids assumed they were going to the woods (Hansel and Gretal) and ended up going someplace else. What if that someplace else was a danger? This goes beyond surprise. Surprise is the guy who takes his girl to the jeweler’s, has her try on a ring, she says “Perfect,” he says, I had it sized will you marry me. Ta dah. Kids love surprises and in this day and age they can still be enjoyed without risking trust. What about the kids who’d have rather gone to the woods. They lose??? I bet kids have less “woods” than toys. Peace, len

  2. Surprises are fun. The little girl with the red Elmo doll wrapped around her neck was all I needed to fall in love with the commerical, and if you ask anyone who knows me, I cannot stand commercials. However, like I said, the joy on her face stole my heart. And like you, Sam, I to will not be signing the petition either. PS nice thoughts

  3. I am so glad you are thinking for yourself and not operating out of reactive emotion, as so many do. I agree 100% and frankly, cannot imagine that people are starting a petition about such an unimportant thing as this commercial. Even among commercials, I can find SOOO many more offensive and destructive commercials, and then, as far as important and ‘petition-worthy’ things go, petitions are pretty low on the list themselves. Look around Washington for important issues that pique your interest/ire. Look at children with nothing to eat, read, or sleep on. There are foster children who are in need of love. There are adults in extreme financial and/or emotional distress who need our financial/emotional support. And this is just in our country. Move to other lands and you can find a bounty of real and urgent issues. If this commercial is our biggest problem, oh how blessed we must be!

    For me, further rarifying the atmosphere that our already pampered children (mine included here) live in is not a worthy cause. Even assuming one thinks it is an ad of questionable value and/or taste, I suggest you use it as an opportunity to discuss the issues that concern you with your child and then move on with the rest of your life. The world is real, and full of things we disagree with. Further, sometimes it is not pretty and only rarely is it politically correct. It behooves us to teach our children to navigate the world, rather than try to insulate them from every potential “bad” influence.

  4. Sorry – Typo. The following sentence should have read:

    Even among commercials, I can find SOOO many more offensive and destructive commercials, and then, as far as important and ‘petition-worthy’ things go, commercials are pretty low on the list themselves.

I would love to hear your thoughts . . .

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s