The Teacher Has Appeared, and Her Name Is Miley Cyrus

When the student is ready, the teacher will appear.”  –Buddhist Proverb

miley cyrusI don’t know Miley Cyrus and don’t feel as though it is my prerogative to comment on the choices she makes in her personal life.  As a fellow human being, certainly my compassion does go out to her and those who love her as she negotiates whatever thorny path it is she’s on.  But she is a performer, and as such she invites (some may argue demands) a reaction.  She is also a public figure and thus makes herself available for public commentary—the large and the small.  So here is mine, small as it may be: It is time, seriously time, to have a national conversation about dignity.

Daily I speak to my sons about dignity—about how they conduct themselves at home, away from home, in public.  There are consequences and even more conversation when they don’t and plenty of praise when they do.  We emphasize that it is possible to be silly, to be intriguing, to be yourself and still maintain your self-respect.

We also try to underscore that there will be plenty of moments in your life when your self-possession unwittingly fails you, when you do something you regret.  We then explain that it’s what you do next that matters, how you conduct yourself in the aftermath.

My sons were too young to watch Cyrus’ most recent performance; but at 9, 8, and 4 it won’t be long.  And certainly (and sadly) if it’s not Miley Cyrus, it will be someone else.  Further, Cyrus does not count as a role model of theirs.  However, outside the four walls of our home I suspect there were plenty of children watching and plenty of young people for whom this performer is (or was) something special.

But at the end of the day it’s not Miley Cyrus’ responsibility to be anyone’s role model.  People don’t set out to be role models; they become such when the choices they make inspire others to positive action.  No one wakes up in the morning and says, “I think today I’d like to become a role model.”  It happens organically, when you’re not looking, by a continuous effort to be the best version of yourself.

Miley Cyrus is not a role model, but her actions do communicate something about the concoction so many performers are forced to become, about the challenges of fame, about the difficulties she battles.

And her actions also show precisely what it is that gets us all talking.

But perhaps we’re talking about the wrong thing.  Maybe instead of talking about Miley Cyrus we should be talking about ourselves—how we talk to one another, engage with one another, how we conduct ourselves, and why this is all so important.


It’s a conversation long overdue and one that I can clearly never stop having with my children.


4 thoughts on “The Teacher Has Appeared, and Her Name Is Miley Cyrus

  1. Beautifully said! I will be sharing your words on my facebook page as well. This is just one of the many flaws we are dealing with. And it just seems to be getting worse. I am a 68 year old grandmother. I lived thru the Rock N’ Roll “revolution.” But somehow, Elvis’ hips are so far removed from what inspires today’s youth it is heartbreaking. Thank you for your beautiful reminder of OUR duty. Dignity! Today and every day

  2. I admire the approach you’ve taken in your response to these recent “events” in pop culture. I myself didn’t bother to watch the VMA’s and really couldn’t care much less about Miss Cyrus but I do agree that her performance was shocking, and can assume that’s exactly what she may have been going for.

    The point is, every time I hear the ongoing gossip of her recent development as a performer I cant help but think that the only issue that can be seen with it is the respect she holds with herself and, much like you said, her dignity, or lack of it. This is a very important message for every single one of us.

    PS- hope that you are doing well!

I would love to hear your thoughts . . .

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s